$10k For Your Thoughts?

| 23 Aug 2017

$10k For Your Thoughts?

In mid July this year, Visa announced that they were offering 50 small businesses in the US food sector $10,000 in technology upgrades and marketing if they stopped accepting cash payments completely.This is part of a pilot project in Visa’s self-proclaimed ‘War On Cash’. Visa were pretty vocal about the project, releasing a statement to the press entitled ‘Visa to Help U.S. Small Businesses Go Cashless’.

Cheque and cash transactions totalled $17 trillion worldwide in 2016, up about 2% from a year prior, according to Visa themselves. The company has also been quoted in the past as saying that cash is their main competitor and they are committed to putting it out of business.

Visa takes a fee from every payment that runs on its network. The more payments that are processed through them, the more revenue they get. Those fees, which can run into the thousands each year, are the reason many small businesses still prefer cash.

From January 1st 2016, Visa (& MasterCard) changed from charging a flat rate for debit card transactions to a percentage fee. Even though the EU has capped interchange fees, retailers in the UK still pay an average of 16p on each credit card transaction, and 5.5p on each debit card transaction. The Irish government decided to lower the rate further and in Budget 2016 the Irish Government set the interchange cap for debit cards at 0.1%. This means that Ireland’s debit card interchange rate is the lowest in Europe. However, it’s still a percentage of the value of a transaction rather than a flat rate fee, so businesses continue to be charged more for larger transactions.

Visa has said it is considering offering similar ‘Cashless’ incentives to UK businesses.

Visa Credit Cards

The idea has been criticised by UK consumer groups, who say cash is still vital for many people.

"As a responsible society we need to look after vulnerable customers who rely on cash" , said James Daley of consumer group Fairer Finance.

Victoria Cleland, the Bank of England's chief cashier recently said that 2.7 million people in the UK rely almost entirely on cash - that's 5% of all adults! The fact is that Visa are incentivising people to do away with cash and that’s not their place.

Targeting cash customers in an aggressive move like this could be viewed as arrogant and could result in these small businesses alienating and losing their customers.

Trading in cash is your legal right. Accepting cash is your legal right and paying in cash is your legal right.

If you as a consumer, tried to pay for your meal in cash only to be told that cash was no longer accepted at that establishment what would you do? If you have a card maybe you choose to pay with it on that occasion. But do you come back? It depends on what you’re buying, how long you waited, where you are and how urgent your need is. Maybe you just leave and go next door where they are happy to accept cash. Maybe you don’t have a card with you or there isn’t enough money in your account at that time. Maybe you just prefer to pay in cash in general.

man paying in bakery

Consumers don’t like being forced into anything; a sale, an email newsletter or a method of payment. And they especially don’t like when big organisations (or even small neighbourhood restaurants) take away their choices. It’s a bit of a risk for a small business to take.

Visa’s argument is that their fees cost less than processing cash would but where’s the proof?

The fact is that once you have robust procedures, well-trained staff and equipment that is suitable for your business and the volume of cash you process, then handling cash is no more expensive than the alternative which is paying card transaction fees, buying digital payment equipment, keeping that equipment updated and ensuring a secure and uninterrupted connection for transactions. You are also still offering your customers a choice and you have backup should you, for some reason, be unable to accept a payment digitally.

Asking a small business owner, responsible for the livelihoods of multiple employees, to risk their profits to line someone else’s pockets is just madness and realistically, Visa will probably be told as much.

Only time will tell how Visa’s ‘War on Cash’ is actually going.

Have 50 small food service owners actually taken Visa up on their offer? Has their footfall increased? Have their customers welcomed the change? As Rod Tidwell once said; ‘Show Me The Money!’.


Images & References:

http://www.foxbusiness.com/features/2017/07/12/visa-takes-war-on-cash-to-restaurants.html

http://uk.pcmag.com/news/90286/visa-offers-restaurants-10k-to-stop-accepting-cash

https://www.reviewjournal.com/business/visa-offers-10k-to-50-businesses-if-they-will-stop-taking-cash/

https://usa.visa.com/about-visa/cashless.html

http://www.bbc.com/news/business-40604373

http://www.iocsave.com/news

https://pixabay.com


 

Share this article



Back to news listings

We are proud to have helped these leading businesses to be even more successful!