Is A Cashless Sweden Really On The Cards?
Danielle Fitzsimons | 20 Mar 2017
Debatable but it’s definitely a subject high on the agenda for both commercial banks and the Riksbank: Sweden’s Central Bank.
Advocates for the move to a cashless society will tell you that it’s already happening. After all 80% of all store transactions are currently completed by card according to the Swedish Trade Federation. Technology is developing fast and apps like Swish and iZettel are making digital payments the norm rather than the exception. And that’s fine because it’s happening by choice. But what about the 20% of transactions that are still cash based?
Is it fair, right, or even legal to force people that may not have, or want access to digital payments or banks for perfectly legitimate reasons, to pay digitally?
Apparently 900 of Sweden’s 1,600 bank branches no longer keep cash on hand or take cash deposits and many, especially in rural areas, no longer have ATMs. Organisations for the elderly fear that those who prefer cash, out of a reluctance to use new technology or simply because they find it easier to keep track of their spending, will be disadvantaged, while educators worry that young people will be tempted to spend money they do not have.
The 2016 World Payments Report stated that the Swedish Central Bank has mandated that all Swedish banks must (by law) offer their customers at least one free payment method; i.e. cash. The most important benefits of cash tend to be overlooked by most. It’s free to use and it’s tangible. And it’s perfectly logical for a person’s preference to be based on these facts. Banks charge for transactions and banking systems crash all the time resulting in a loss of account access for customers.

And then there’s another more worrying factor; what if the bank itself fails and can’t meet its financial obligations to its customers?
The Riksbank recently announced that it would investigate ways to introduce an electronic version of cash as a supplement to notes and coins. For the Swedish Central Bank, this is also a matter of financial inclusion. “We are also doing this for the people who do not have, do not want to have, or cannot have access to the current version of the payment system, so that they can also manage their payments safely and efficiently” Cecilia Skingsley, the Central Bank’s deputy governor said. According to her, while it has not been demonstrated yet in practice, in theory, e-kronas could allow everyone to manage their payments without commercial banks. To achieve this, the Riksbank will have to create a complete payment system for the e-krona accounts, equipped with debit cards and all the other infrastructure and associated services now provided by private banks.
But this doesn’t address another important concern for dedicated cash users. Many people just don’t like the idea of every single transaction they make being tracked, recorded and held in some digital environment to be used for, at the very least, aggregated marketing purposes!
Several critics – including the inventor of iZettel, Jacob de Greer – have asked whether an entirely electronic system in which every single payment is recorded is not a threat to privacy. A cashless society may prevent loss due to counterfeit notes but according to Sweden’s Justice Ministry, the number of electronic-fraud cases soared to 140,000 in 2014, more than double the comparable number a decade earlier.
This then results in increasing digital security costs for banks, so where’s the benefit? The fact is that not everyone using cash is trying to hide something. To suggest otherwise is quite simply propaganda, most likely from sources with their own agendas.
For these and other social reasons, Niklas Arvidsson, an associate professor specialising in payment systems innovation at Stockholm’s Royal Institute of Technology (KTH) says, cash is not dead quite yet. “Even if, in the next few years, Swedes use almost no cash at all, going 100% cashless needs a political decision,” he said. “The idea of cash, even in Sweden, remains very strong.”
Data & Image Sources: International Money Reform Blog | The Guardian Online | ATM Marketplace Online | World Payments Report 2016 | Wallpaper Cave
Share this article...
Back to news listings